Spelling and grammar mistakes: Yes, I do notice them. And, yes, they do count against you. A query letter is basically your application for a writing job. To earn a job writing, you must be familiar with the tools of the language: spelling and grammar. 'Nuff said.Try to give yourself a fighting chance before you hit "send" on that emailed query, okay?
Typos: One typo I may forgive but a letter riddled with "teh" instead of "the" is getting rejected. Attention to detail matters.
You addressed me by another agent's name or no name at all or you included me in a mass-emailed query.
You included the phrase "Cos, bitch, you're gonna love this!" in your query letter. (Yes, seriously. Not sure what he was thinking with that one.)
You spent five paragraphs telling me A.) how much you love writing, B.) how long you have been writing, C.) how much you have always wanted to be a writer or D.) all of the above. Not to seem heartless but...I don't care about any of this. By including this in your query, you're wasting precious space. Again, think of the query as a cover letter for a job. Would you write this a cover letter? "I have wanted to be a marketing manager since I was six years old. I spent my entire childhood marketing all of my friend's dogs, cats and hamsters...By the time I was in high school I had moved onto marketing for the Piggly Wiggly down the street, dreaming of one day marketing for a giant multi-national corporation in New York City." No, you wouldn't because it sounds ridiculous. Well, it sounds ridiculous in a query, too.
You told me that you'd previously self-published the book you're querying about but now want to reach a wider audience. Unless you sold several thousand copies of that self-published book (we're talking five digits here, kids), a legit trade publisher won't be interested. And neither will an agent. Write a new book instead!
You told me that you were previously published by someone like PublishAmerica... and meant it. This is akin to telling me that you would consider yourself previously published if you had Xeroxed pages of your manuscript and stapled them together.
You didn't read my submission guidelines: How do I know you didn't read my submission guidelines? Because you: A.) included an unsolicited attachment with your query, B.) snail-mailed your query, C.) didn't cut-and-paste the first five to ten pages of your manuscript into the email with your query letter, D.) sent me a query for a subject matter that I clearly don't represent like screenplays, poems, or Christian fiction, or E.) all of the above.
Thursday, November 13, 2008
Why I may have rejected your query letter this week:
Lotsa reasons, some of which you can't control. But here are some things you can control in your query letter, and by doing so, increase your odds that I'm actually going to read the entire thing and possibly ask for more:
tags:
queries,
query tips,
queryfail
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



15 comments:
ouch.. the "bitch please" phrase is really insulting and un-necessary. I get offended when strangers email me on myspace and think they can call me bitch just cos I look "cool," oh please...
I cannot believe what agents have to deal with. How do you do it without stapling your fingers to the desk and shouting at the top of your lungs?
An author on LJ, who is also a professor, asked the followers of his blog if he should accept incorrectly formatted assignments from college students. The overwhelming response from most people was no. Those students need to learn to follow instructions before they get to the real world.
Guess what folks, this is the real world...
http://newguydave.livejournal.com/
I'm meticulous in following the agencies guidelines. And I’m sure I’ve not made most of the mistakes you mentioned (such as talking about my love for writing, yo b@^#%, or improperly addressing the letter, etc). Yet, no such luck with my query. On a side note, I don’t see how people have spelling errors. That’s fairly easy to catch using Microsoft Word. (though not easy in blogging, arrhh)
But your post has motivated me to take again look at my 'query in process'.
Valuable advice, indeed.
I used to write for Piggly Wiggly. Does that help?
From this and other Swivet entries its totally clear how to tick off an agent, but how to impress them? That still remains a mystery.
I do appreciate two things out of rejections:
a) Being informed I've been rejected.
b) The reminder of how subjective this whole process is.
All the same, it is pretty awful the abuse agents get dished out because of how highly personal (and creative) writers tend to be.
You forgot to add the "My Book is the Next Harry Potter"
Just a quick concern. I sent you a query last summer. Then, on your blog, you mentioned that you had gotten through all your queries and if we hadn't heard from you, we should requery. So, in September, I queried again. I still have received no response. Should I query you a third time? Perhaps from a different email address?
Lisa Iriarte (Assassin's Nightmare)
Can I include the phrase, "'Cos, my liege, you're gonna love it, and if you don't, then off with my head!" next time I send you a series proposal? I have a feeling Madame DeFarge had better appear as a supporting character if I do.
How about if I added, "I wrote this book because it'll piss off my big fat Italian family"? =p
You don't read Christian fiction? You mean I just printed and express mailed my 300,000 word story about a boy who feels unloved until Jesus helps him solve a murder mystery with a talking dog for nothing?
Sex Mahoney for President
"You told me that you'd previously self-published the book you're querying about but now want to reach a wider audience. Unless you sold several thousand copies of that self-published book (we're talking five digits here, kids), a legit trade publisher won't be interested. And neither will an agent. Write a new book instead!"
I've been trying to explain this to a group of people who have published under a probably-dodgy new imprint (and yes, they're paying small amounts to do this), but will they listen to me? Pah.
Their "publisher" has assured them all that he doesn't take any rights at all, and they can easily get out of the contract with him, so they will have no trouble if they find a big publisher who wants to take their books on: they're convinced.
It's a terrible, terrible shame that more writers don't listen to you.
Jane: You're describing precisely why I broke ties with one of my local writing groups. Sorry, guys. PublishAmerica is NOT a "legitimate, advance-paying publisher."
PA pays a "symbolic" advance of $1. And, from what I've read, even more symbolic royalties for a lot of authors.
I can't imagine selling the rights of first publication of my manuscript for so little.
Am learning the ins and outs of query letters and synopses this week. Thanks so much for such posts here at The Swivet!
I've self-published with the "probably-dodgy" new imprint and wouldn't dream of sending that particular book out to agents/publishers, but surely, having just wrote, edited and COMPLETED a book tells the agent/publisher a great deal about the writer-in-waiting?
And that's that he or she has the stamina to finish a full-sized novel?
Isn't that a plus in the cover letter? Or are all self-published written (pun not intended) off as poor, deluded things?
Post a Comment